What Is a Good Close Rate for a Home Service Business?
Close rate benchmarks vary by trade, job type, and channel. A 50 percent close rate on electrical service calls is mediocre. On a $15,000 roofing replacement, it is exceptional. Here are the actual benchmarks and what moves them.
Key takeaways
- Close rate benchmarks differ by trade and job type by 30 to 40 percentage points. Blending them into one company-wide number produces a figure that drives no useful decision.
- Speed of follow-up is the single largest controllable driver of close rate for estimate-based jobs. Leads contacted within 5 minutes of inquiry close at 21 times the rate of leads contacted after 30 minutes.
- A high company close rate can mask a volume problem. Closing 90 percent of 6 estimates per week is worse than closing 50 percent of 20 estimates per week.
- Offering a payment option (financing) at estimate delivery increases close rate on jobs above $3,000 by 15 to 25 percentage points in most trades.
Close rate benchmarks vary widely by trade, job type, and channel, and most industry averages blur all three into a single number that drives no useful decision. A 50 percent close rate on electrical service calls is mediocre. A 50 percent close rate on $15,000 roofing replacements is exceptional. The context determines whether the number is a problem or a strength.
Understanding where your close rate falls requires knowing what you are comparing it against. This post breaks it down by trade and job type, identifies the factors that drive variance within each, and explains two cases where the close rate number misleads.
Why benchmarks vary by job type
Service calls and repair jobs close at high rates because the customer is already on-site with a problem. The tech is present, the issue is visible, and the customer needs the problem solved today. A plumber diagnosing a burst pipe has a fundamentally different sales environment than a roofer submitting a bid for a replacement project.
The close rate drops as the job size increases and the time between estimate and decision lengthens. A $250 drain cleaning closes at 80 percent. A $12,000 roof replacement closes at 45 percent. Neither number is good or bad on its own. Both reflect the nature of the transaction.
The useful comparison is your close rate versus the benchmark for that specific job type in your market, not versus an industry average that mixes service calls with large project bids.
Text Clint: "what is my close rate by job type for the last 90 days?"
Close rate table by trade
These benchmarks reflect typical ranges for owner-operated and small-fleet businesses in competitive markets. Benchmarks will be at the lower end of each range in high-competitor-density metros and at the upper end in smaller markets with fewer alternatives.
| Trade and Job Type | Typical Close Rate Range |
|---|---|
| HVAC service and repair | 70 to 85 percent |
| HVAC equipment replacement | 35 to 55 percent |
| Plumbing service and repair | 72 to 88 percent |
| Electrical service and repair | 68 to 82 percent |
| Roofing retail replacement | 40 to 60 percent |
| Roofing insurance claim | 55 to 75 percent |
| Landscaping maintenance proposals | 30 to 50 percent |
| Cleaning recurring proposals | 40 to 60 percent |
| Pest control recurring proposals | 50 to 70 percent |
| HVAC maintenance agreements (field offer) | 20 to 30 percent |
Service and repair rates are high because of immediate need. Equipment replacement and project bids are lower because they involve a capital decision with multiple competing quotes. Recurring service proposals sit in between because the customer is comparing ongoing cost against the convenience of automatic service.
Text Clint: "compare my close rate on HVAC service calls vs equipment replacement quotes this year"
The factors that move close rate
Within any benchmark range, five factors have the most consistent impact on close rate:
Speed of follow-up is the most powerful single variable for estimate-based jobs. Research from MIT and InsideSales.com shows that leads contacted within 5 minutes of an inquiry convert at 21 times the rate of leads contacted after 30 minutes. For a roofing or HVAC replacement business that collects estimate requests by form or phone, the time between the request and the first contact from the business is the largest controllable driver of whether the job closes; the mechanics live in how to track response time and speed to lead.
How the estimate is presented changes the close rate materially for jobs above $3,000. A written estimate emailed as a PDF closes at a lower rate than the same estimate walked through in person or via a video call. When the tech or estimator explains the work, the customer is buying a solution from a person, not comparing line items from two emails. In-person estimate presentations close 15 to 25 percentage points higher than email-only delivery for replacement and project jobs.
Whether the tech explains the why is the equivalent factor on service calls. A tech who explains why the repair is needed, what would happen if it is deferred, and what the fix involves closes at higher rates than a tech who states a price and waits. The explanation converts the customer from someone reacting to a cost into someone understanding a value.
Offering a payment option on jobs above $3,000 removes the most common reason a customer says no: they cannot pay the full amount at once. Financing offered at the point of estimate delivery increases close rate by 15 to 25 percentage points on equipment replacement and large service jobs. Most CRMs connect to financing partners (Wisetack, GreenSky, FTL Finance) that allow same-day approval in the field.
Competitor density in the local market is the factor the business cannot control directly. In a market with 40 HVAC companies, a customer requesting three quotes is standard practice. In a market with 8, a customer may accept the first credible quote. Geographic market conditions set the floor on close rate for replacement and project jobs. For the broader pipeline picture see how to track open pipeline value.
Text Clint: "what is my close rate on jobs where the estimate was followed up within 24 hours vs. after 24 hours?"
High close rate as a warning sign
A close rate above 80 percent on estimate-based jobs (not service calls) typically indicates one of two problems.
The first is a volume problem. If a business is closing 85 percent of its estimates but only sending 10 estimates per week, it is closing 8.5 jobs per week. A business closing 50 percent of 30 estimates per week closes 15 jobs. The lower close rate business is producing more revenue. High close rate on low estimate volume means the sales funnel is not generating enough opportunities, not that the sales process is excellent.
The second is a pricing problem. A close rate well above benchmark for the job type often means the business is underpriced relative to the market. Customers who are never surprised by the quote price close immediately. Customers choosing between a fair price and a below-market price always choose below-market. If close rate climbs as margins deteriorate, the two metrics are related.
Monitor close rate alongside estimate volume and average ticket size. All three together tell a coherent story. Close rate alone does not.
Text Clint: "how many estimates did we send this month, and what was the average ticket on the ones that closed?"
How to improve close rate systematically
The four levers that move close rate reliably, without changing pricing:
Reduce response time. Set a hard internal standard for how quickly estimates are sent or calls are returned after a lead comes in. Measure response time per lead source and flag any average above 4 hours for estimate requests.
Require in-person or video estimate delivery for jobs above a threshold. If the job is above $2,500, the estimate is presented by a person, not emailed. This is a process change, not a skill change.
Add a follow-up sequence. Most estimates that do not close on first contact are simply not followed up. A two-touch follow-up (48 hours and 7 days after estimate delivery) recovers 10 to 20 percent of estimates that stalled. The follow-up message is one sentence: "Wanted to check if you had any questions on the estimate we sent." No pressure. No deadline. Just contact. The full cadence sits in estimate follow-up cadence for home services.
Offer financing at every estimate above $3,000. Make it part of the standard estimate presentation, not an afterthought when the customer hesitates. "We also work with a financing partner if you want to spread the cost over 12 or 24 months" takes 10 seconds. The customers who would have declined due to cash flow now have a path to yes.
Text Clint: "which techs or estimators have the highest and lowest close rates on replacement quotes this quarter?"
How Clint Tracks Close Rate by Job Type and Tech
Clint connects to your CRM and surfaces close rate broken out by job type, technician, lead source, and time period. Ask "what is my close rate by job type this month?" and Clint pulls the estimates sent, the jobs closed, and the rate for each category. Ask "which techs have the lowest close rate on service calls?" and Clint returns the comparison across your team so coaching conversations have a specific data point behind them, the same lens used in home service KPIs: the complete metrics playbook.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
4 questions home service owners actually ask about this.
01Should I track close rate on service calls and replacement jobs separately?
Yes. Combining them produces a number that explains nothing. Service call close rates run 70 to 88 percent. Replacement job close rates run 35 to 55 percent. A company average of 60 percent tells you nothing about performance in either category. Track them separately and benchmark each against its own range.
02What counts as a close for close rate calculation?
A job that is accepted by the customer and results in a scheduled appointment or signed agreement. Estimates that are sent but not responded to within 30 days should be counted as not closed. Estimates that are pending should not be included in the denominator until they resolve. The calculation is: closed jobs divided by total estimates that have reached a final status (closed or declined), excluding open pending estimates.
03My close rate dropped last quarter. What should I check first?
Check estimate volume and response time first. If volume held steady and response time increased (common when the office is understaffed or a CSR turned over), that explains most close rate drops on estimate-based jobs. If response time is unchanged, check the average days between estimate sent and job accepted on the jobs that did close. If that number increased, customers are taking longer to decide, which usually indicates more competition or a pricing sensitivity in the market.
04Is a lower close rate acceptable for a premium-priced business?
Yes, with a constraint. A business positioned at the top of the market with higher average tickets should expect a lower close rate than market average and higher revenue per closed job. The test is revenue per estimate sent (total revenue divided by total estimates sent). A business closing 40 percent at an average ticket of $6,500 earns $2,600 per estimate sent. A competitor closing 65 percent at an average ticket of $3,800 earns $2,470. The premium business wins the economics despite the lower close rate.
See Clint in action
Clint is the pre-built AI for home service shops. Connect your CRM, email, and phone system in minutes and the agents run on your real data.